Why Red Cedar Wood Moth Balls Are Superior: A Comparative Analysis

How do natural red cedar moth balls stack up against traditional chemical options? Find out with this in-depth comparison of toxicity, effectiveness, and more.

February 8, 2024
min read
Subscribe to our blog and get a FREE Red Cedar Sachet.
a piece of cedar wood on top of cedar chippings
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Shipping rates apply. £1.95 UK, £4.95 Other
In this article:

For generations, toxic mothballs have been the go-to solution for protecting clothing and fabrics from moth damage and infestations. The strong chemical fumes emitted by traditional mothballs do deter moths and other insects, but they come at a huge cost - harming your health, home, and the environment.

There is a natural, non-toxic alternative that research shows can be just as effective, if not better than chemical mothballs - red cedar wood moth balls. In this in-depth comparative analysis, we will look at the key differences between traditional chemical mothballs and natural cedar moth balls. After reviewing the pros and cons, it will become clear why red cedar is the optimal choice for safe, eco-friendly moth prevention in your home.

Traditional Chemical Mothballs - The Toxic Standby

For over a century, people have turned to chemical mothballs as a go-to solution for keeping moths away from valued clothing and textiles. Traditional mothballs are small balls of chemical pesticides that slowly turn from solid to vapor. Two main active ingredients are used:

Naphthalene - a hydrocarbon found in coal tar and petroleum distillates. Naphthalene mothballs emit an extremely strong, unpleasant odour as they off-gas.

Paradichlorobenzene (PDB) - an organochloride compound that also releases harsh fumes as it evaporates.

Both chemicals are registered pesticides with the EPA and are highly effective at repelling moths and other insects. However, they come with numerous downsides:

Toxicity in Humans

Exposure to naphthalene and PDB mothball fumes poses significant health risks, especially to vulnerable populations like children and the elderly. Possible effects include:

  • Headaches, dizziness, fatigue
  • Nausea and vomiting
  • Shortness of breath
  • Eye, nose, and throat irritation
  • Anaemia and jaundice
  • Liver and kidney damage

Long term exposure may also be linked to cancer. Pregnant women should avoid chemical mothballs, as they may harm the unborn child.

Environmental Contamination

Chemical mothball vapor spreads easily from homes into the surrounding environment. PDB and naphthalene residues have been frequently detected in soil, air, and water samples near residential areas. These chemicals persist in the environment for years and accumulate up the food chain.

As broad-spectrum pesticides, traditional mothballs also kill beneficial insects like pollinators and predators. Their production from petrochemicals and coal tar also has upstream environmental impacts.

Property Damage Concerns

The strong vapours and direct contact staining potential of chemical mothballs can also damage household materials like wood, fabrics, plastic, and rubber. Continued exposure degrades and discolours possessions stored in contaminated areas.

Flammability Issues

Both PDB and naphthalene are flammable chemicals, posing fire risks if exposure to sparks or flames occurs. Mothball vapours can ignite or explode if too strongly concentrated in an enclosed space.

Due to these significant toxicity and environmental impact concerns, many regions have now banned or restricted the sale of traditional chemical mothballs. While still available in some areas, increasing awareness about their risks has led many consumers to search for safer alternatives like red cedar moth balls.

Red Cedar Moth Balls - The Natural, Non-Toxic Option

Red cedar moth balls provide a plant-based, non-toxic alternative to traditional chemical mothballs. Instead of toxic pesticides, red cedar balls utilize natural essential oils and compounds inherently found in cedar wood to repel moths the natural way.

Red cedar moth balls are small blocks or spheres carved directly from the heartwood of red cedar trees. Scientifically known as Juniperus Virginiana, red cedar belongs to the cypress family and grows abundantly across North America.

The wood contains oils and organic compounds like cedrol that act as natural insecticides but are harmless to humans and pets. As the cedar slowly erodes, these active ingredients diffuse into the air providing lasting moth protection.

Here are some of the major benefits of using red cedar moth balls:

Completely Non-Toxic

Red cedar moth balls contain no synthetic chemicals or pesticides. The cedar oil aroma and vapours are completely harmless to humans and pets, even with long-term exposure. You can use cedar worry-free around children, pregnant women, and pets.

Long Lasting Protection

The oils slowly released from the cedar balls provide enduring moth prevention for years. As the wood erodes, it continually reveals fresh cedar underneath for ongoing repellent power. Just occasional sanding restores efficacy.

Pleasant Natural Aroma

Rather than a harsh chemical smell, red cedar moth balls emit an appealing, soothing woodsy scent. The aroma is refreshing for humans while offensive to moths and insects.

Safe for All Fabrics

Red cedar moth balls will not stain or damage delicate fabrics like wool, silk, cashmere, or synthetics. There are no problematic chemical residues. Clothing can be stored safely without risk of discoloration.

100% Biodegradable & Renewable

Cedarwood is a totally renewable, sustainable resource. Cedar balls biodegrade naturally without issue. They are sourced ethically from certified North American forestry operations.

Repels Other Pests

In addition to deterring moths, the cedarwood aroma also naturally repels other insects like carpet beetles, silverfish, cockroaches, ants, and more. It creates an aromatic pest perimeter when placed in closets, drawers, baseboards, and windows.

Affordable & Readily Available

Quality cedar moth balls are available at most home and hardware stores. Bulk purchases online can make them even more budget friendly.

With effectiveness equal to or better than chemical mothballs but none of the toxic downsides, red cedar is clearly the optimal choice for safe, eco-friendly moth prevention in the home.

Direct Comparison of Chemical vs. Cedar Moth Balls

Now that we have covered the basics of both options, let's directly compare chemical mothballs and red cedar balls across some key factors:

comparison graph cedar wood vs chemical mothballs
Cedar wood vs chemical mothballs

Safety & Toxicity

Chemical - Very toxic to humans and pets, especially with long-term exposure. Vulnerable groups like children and pregnant women are at highest risk but effects can occur in anyone.

Cedar - Completely non-toxic and harmless to humans, pets, and the environment. Can be safely used around kids and pregnant women.

Effectiveness Against Moths

Chemical - Very effective due to the strong pesticidal chemical vapours. Harsh smell drives moths away quickly.

Cedar - Also highly effective due to the natural essential oils offensive to moths. Pleasant cedar aroma deters moths for years. Efficacy is equal or possibly better than chemicals.

Impact on Fabrics and Dyes

Chemical - Fumes and direct contact with fabrics causes discoloration and degradation over time. Staining is common.

Cedar - Leaves no stains, odours, or residue on clothing or textiles. Safe for all fabrics.

Flammability Risk

Chemical - Major fire hazard. Chemical vapours are flammable and can ignite if concentrated in a confined space.

Cedar - Actually has natural fire retardant properties and is used in flue pipes and fireplace construction. Oils self-extinguish embers.

Environmental Impact

Chemical - PDB and naphthalene contamination are common near homes. Vapours and residue collect in soil, air, and water for years damaging ecosystems.

Cedar - 100% natural and renewable. Biodegrades rapidly without issue. Supportive of beneficial insect life. Sustainably harvested from managed forests.

Cost Effectiveness

Chemical - Very cheap initially but damage to health, home, and environment creates major long term costs. Frequent replacement needed.

Cedar - Slightly more expensive up front but lasts for many years. One-time investment provides long-lasting value. Bulk discounts available.

Aroma Properties

Chemical - Strong, unpleasant chemical smell lingers in storage areas. Many find odour offensive and irritating.

Cedar - Fresh, pleasant woodsy scent. Natural aroma is enjoyable and soothing for humans.

Ease of Use

Chemical - Must be handled extremely cautiously due to toxicity concerns. Use of gloves and masks recommended.

Cedar - No special precautions needed. Can be placed by hand wherever needed, even in delicate garments.

Global Availability

Chemical - Restricted or banned in many regions but still available in most countries.

Cedar - Renewable resource easily produced anywhere red cedar trees grow, including much of North America.

Conclusion - Why Red Cedar is the Clear Winner

In conclusion, when all factors are objectively compared side-by-side, red cedar wood moth balls are superior to traditional chemical mothballs in nearly every way.

Cedar balls match or exceed the effectiveness of chemicals thanks to powerful natural oils that safely deter moths and other insects from fabrics. Users reap reliable moth prevention for years from just a one-time purchase of all-natural cedar balls.

There are absolutely no concerns about toxicity, fumes, stains, or environmental damage that come with chemical pesticides. Red cedar moth balls provide pest protection you can feel good about using in your family's home.

The renewable, sustainable nature of red cedar gives it a huge advantage over synthetically produced chemicals that deplete resources and damage ecosystems. And the affordable price means it protects your wallet as well as your clothing investment.

For maximum fabric protection without risky chemicals, red cedarwood is the clear mothball winner. Make the healthy, eco-friendly choice and rely on the natural power of red cedar to send moths packing for good. Your clothes and conscience will thank you!

Back to blog
Share this article

About Wood Blocks

Our mission is to empower you with the knowledge to curate a wardrobe that not only reflects your personal style but also aligns with environmentally friendly practices. From exploring the wonders of natural mothballs and sustainable garment storage to diving deep into DIY solutions and green living, we're here to guide you on a journey towards a more eco-conscious, stylish, and intentional lifestyle.

Other articles you might like

Shop Natural Red Cedar Mothballs

Pick your bundle based on your home size. You can always add extra blocks, rings and sachets.